Supreme Court Docket

Winter 2009

Justices of the Supreme Court

Chief Justice

Gerry Alexander

Justice

Charles W. Johnson

Justice

Barbara A. Madsen

Justice

Richard B. Sanders

Justice

Tom Chambers

Justice

Susan Owens

Justice

Mary E. Fairhurst

Justice

James M. Johnson

Justice

Debra L. Stephens


Appointive Officers of the Supreme Court

Clerk

Ronald R. Carpenter

Court Commissioner

Steven Goff

Reporter

Tim Fuller

Administrator for the Courts

Jeff Hall

State Law Librarian

Kay Newman

Bailiff

Steve Englehorn


Order

Pursuant to Supreme Court Administrative Rule 6, the Justices of the Supreme Court are assigned to the Departments of the Court for the 2009 Session as indicated below:

Department One

Hon. Gerry L. Alexander, Chief Justice

Hon. Charles W. Johnson Hon. Richard B. Sanders
Hon. Susan Owens Hon. James M. Johnson

Department Two

Hon. Gerry L. Alexander, Chief Justice

Hon. Barbara A. Madsen Hon. Tom Chambers
Hon. Mary E. Fairhurst Hon. Debra L. Stephens


Notice to Attorneys

Regular Sessions of the Court begin in January (Winter), May (Spring), and September (Fall) of each year.

Cases set for the mornings are subject to call at 9:00 a.m. Those set in the afternoon are subject to call at 1:30 p.m., unless otherwise noted.

The Court will sometimes take a short recess following the first case in the morning and the first case in the afternoon.

Motion days in the 2009 Winter Session, will be:

January 6, 2009
February 3, 2009
March 3, 2009
March 31, 2009
April 28, 2009

Settings will not be altered or vacated by the Chief Justice except upon a showing of unavoidable cause.

As provided in RCW 2.32.070, counsel of record and criminal defendants shall be supplied a copy of opinion without charge.


The titles of the cases listed in this docket are not the official titles for purposes of opinions


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

January 13, 2009

81324-8 (C/A 58823-1-I)
Discretionary Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

In re the Personal Restraint Petition of

Mark David Mattson,
          Respondent.

Hon. Rob McKenna
Alex Kostin
Gregory Rosen
John Samson

Gregory Link

80948-8 (C/A 36606-1-II)
Discretionary Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Tyler Sherwood King,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Arthur Curtis
John Peterson

Mark Muenster


1:30 P.M.

200,569-1 (WSBA #18616)

20 MINUTES PER SIDE


In re:

A. Mark Vanderveen,
Attorney at Law.



Kurt Bulmer

Christine Gray (WSBA)

81102-4 (C/A 60780-4-I)
Discretionary Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

In re the Personal Restraint Petition of

Michael W. McKiearnan,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Janice Ellis
Seth Aaron Fine

Jeffrey Ellis


1:30 P.M.

Olympia

January 15, 2009

TWO CASES ONLY IN P.M. – NO MORNING CASES

81062-1 (C/A 25597-2-III)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Petitioner,
     v.
Ryan J. O’Hara,
          Respondent.

Hon. Steven Tucker
Andrew Metts, III

Jordan Broome McCabe

PRO TEM: SEINFELD, J.P.T.

STEPHENS, J. RECUSED

80684-5 (C/A 34808-0-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Paul W. Post,
          Petitioner,
     v.
City of Tacoma; City of Tacoma Department of Public Works, Building and Land Use Services Division; Risk Management Alternatives, Inc.; and Charles Solverson,
          Respondents.

Everett Holum


Debra Casparian
Joanne Henry


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

January 20, 2009

81202-1 (C/A 57938-0-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Eufemia “Emma” Morgan, Nancy Pitchford and Daniel McGillivray, individually and on behalf of all the members of the class of personssimilarly situated,
          Respondents,
     v.
Gerald Kingen and Jane Doe Kingen, husband and wife and the marital community comprised thereof, and Scott Switzer and Jane Doe Switzer, husband and wife and the marital community comprised thereof,
          Petitioners.

Claudia Kilbreath
Shane Moloney




William McInerney, Jr.




PRO TEM:  SWEENEY, J.P.T. FAIRHURST, J. RECUSED

80841-4 (C/A 57420-5-I & 57469-8-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Steven Ray Heddrick, Jr.,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Daniel Satterberg
Randi Austell

Casey Grannis

PRO TEM:  SWEENEY, J.P.T. FAIRHURST, J. RECUSED


1:30 P.M.

81022-2 (C/A 35733-0-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Dot Foods, Inc.,
          Petitioner,
     v.
Washington Department of Revenue,
          Respondent.

Howard Goodfriend
Jacquelyn Beatty

Hon. Rob McKenna
Cameron Comfort

80998-4 (C/A 24076-2-III)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Eric Burt, Gary Edwards, Sherry Hartford, Joann Irwin, John Moore, Clifford Pease, David Snell, Harold Snively, Alan Walter, Dustin West, Paul-David Winters, Cheri Sterlin, Laura Coleman, Charles Crow, Richard “Jason” Morgan,
          Respondent,

Washington State Department of Corrections,
          Respondent,
     v.
Allan Parmelee,
          Petitioner.
These Respondents are pro se






Hon. Rob McKenna
  Peter Berney/Daniel Judge &
  Jay Geck
Michael Kahrs
Alex Brown
PRO TEM:  HOUGHTON, J.P.T. FAIRHURST, J. RECUSED


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

January 22, 2009

THREE CASES ONLY – TWO IN A.M. – ONE IN P.M.

80720-5 (C/A 34321-5-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Kitsap County Deputy Sheriffs Guild,
          Petitioner,
     and
Deputy Brian La France and Jane Doe La France, and the marital community composed thereof,
          Plaintiffs,
     v.
Kitsap County,
          Respondent.

James Cline
  Christina Sherman





Hon. Russell Hauge
Jacquelyn Moore Aufderheide

PRO TEM:  KULIK, J.P.T. FAIRHURST, J., RECUSED

80811-2 (C/A 35219-2-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

James Tomlinson,
          Petitioner,
     v.
Puget Sound Freight Lines,
          Respondent,
Department of Labor & Industries of the State of Washington,
          Defendant.

Stanley Rumbaugh
  John Wallace

Jerald Keene
Michael Weier

PRO TEM:  KULIK, J.P.T. FAIRHURST, J., RECUSED


1:30 P.M.

80922-4 (C/A 34630-3-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Jesse Magana,
          Petitioner,
     v.





Hyundai Motor America; Hyundai Motor Company,
          Respondent,

     and
Ricky and Angela Smith, husband and wife, Dennis Nylander and Jane Doe Nylander, husband and wife,
          Defendants.

Paul Whelan/Ray Kahler
Derek Vanderwood
Peter O'Neil
Michael Withey
Alisa Brodkowitz
Charles Wiggins
Kenneth Masters

Heather Cavanaugh
Michael King
 Gregory Miller
 James Lobsenz
Douglas Foley

PRO TEM:  KULIK, J.P.T. FAIRHURST, J., RECUSED


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

February 10, 2009

79509-6 (C/A 33373-2-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,

     v.
Richard Edward Sibert,
          Petitioner.

Hon. L. Michael Golden
J. Bradley Meagher


Manek Mistry
Jodi Backlund

78611-9 (Consolidated w/78876-6 & 79074-4)
(C/A 23023-6-III, 54975-8-I, 56318-1-I)
Petitions for Review Granted

Graham's Review Granted Solely on the Issue of the Firearm Enhancement

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Aro Te´ Jhon Williams-Walker,
          Petitioner.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Curtis Eugene Graham,
          Petitioner.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Matthew R. Ruth,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Steven Tucker
Mark Lindsey

Susan Gasch


Hon. Janice Ellis
Thomas Curtis

Susan Wilk


Hon. Janice Ellis
Thomas Curtis

Andrew Zinner


1:30 P.M.

80878-3 (C/A 35383-1-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Abbey Road Group, LLC, a Washington limited liability company; Karl J. Thun andVirginia S. Thun, husband and wife; Thomas Pavolka; and Virginia Leslie Revocable Trust; and William and Louise Leslie Family Revocable Trust,
          Petitioners,
     v.
City of Bonney Lake, a Washington municipal corporation,
          Respondent.

Loren Combs
Gregory Amann




Jeffrey Ganson
Lisa Worthington-Brown

81003-6 (C/A 57328-4-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Cambridge Townhomes, LLC, a Washington limited liability company; Polygon Northwest Company, a Washington general partnership,
          Respondent,
     v.
4 Bees Siding, Inc., a Washington corporation; Courtesy Glass, Inc., d/b/a Pacific Decktec, a Washington corporation, Giard Construction LLC, a Washington Limited Liability Company; Interwest Industries, Inc., a Washington corporation, Janes Brothers Waterproofing, Inc., a Washington corporation; United Development Corporation d/b/a Mill Creek Landscaping Services, a Washington corporation;
          Defendants,
Pacific Star Roofing, Inc., a Washington corporation,
          Respondent,
P.J. Interprize, Inc., a Washington corporation,
          Petitioner,
Puget Sound Foundation Services, Inc., a Washington corporation; Creative Concrete, Inc., a Washington corporation; J.S. Contracting, Inc, a Washington corporation,
          Defendants,
Gerald Utley,
          Petitioner/Intervener.

Jerret Sale
Deborah Carstens










Gregory Turner

Eileen McKillop







Mark Clausen


9:00 A.M.

Pierce College

February 12, 2009

THREE CASES ONLY – TWO IN A.M. – ONE IN P.M.

80850-3 (C/A 56935-0-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Timothy Earl Pugh,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Daniel Satterberg
James Whisman

Maureen Cyr

80941-1 (C/A 25255-8-III)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Anthony Gaylord Garvin,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Ronald Zirkle
Kevin Eilmes

Casey Grannis

PRO TEM: SEINFELD, J.P.T.

STEPHENS, J. RECUSED


1:30 P.M.

81328-1 (C/A 58932-6-I)
Petition for Review Granted

Issue Raised In Answer Also Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

In re the Estate of
Pamela L. Kissinger,

Deceased.


Mark Leemon

Jean O'Loughlin


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

February 24, 2009

80996-8 (C/A 24981-6-III)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Amber Kappelman,
          Petitioner,
     v.
Theodore J. Lutz,
          Respondent.

Gordon Carey, Jr.


Jackson Welch

PRO TEM: QUINN-BRINTNALL, J.P.T.

STEPHENS, J. RECUSED

80888-1 (Chelan 07-2-00060-1)

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Kimme Putman,
          Appellant,
     v.
Wenatchee Valley Medical Center, P.S., a Washington professional service corporation; Patrick J. Wendt, M.D.; David B. Levitsky, J.D., Shawn C. Kelley, M.D.; John Doe No. 1; John Doe No. 2; Jane Doe No. 1; and Jane Doe No. 2,
          Respondents.

Ron Perey
Douglas Weinmaster
Carla Tachau Lawrence
Robert Peck

Sherry Hemming Rogers
Michael Budelsky
Pamela Okano



1:30 P.M.

200,570-5 (WSBA #13836)

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

In re:

Terry J. Preszler,
Attorney at Law.


Kurt Bulmer

Joanne Abelson (WSBA)

80480-0 (C/A 56265-7-I)
Petition for Review Granted

Cons. w/80584-9 & 81083-4
(King 06-2-03941-6 & 06-2-10204-5)

30 MINUTES PER SIDE

MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT RECORD - PASSED
TO THE MERITS

Satomi Owners Association, a Washington nonprofit corporation,
          Respondent,
     v.
Satomi, LLC, a Washington limited liability company,
          Petitioner.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Blakeley Commons Condominium Association, a Washington corporation,
     Other Party,
     v.
Blakeley Commons, LLC, a Washington corporation; Intracorp Real Estate, LLC, a Washington corporation; John and Jane Does 1 through 20, individuals; Contractor Does 21 through 35, entities conducting business in Washington,
          Respondent,
     and
Blakeley Village, LLC, a Washington corporation,
          Appellant,

     and
Intracorp Real Estate, LLC, a Washington corporation,
          Respondent,
     v.
Accurate Siding, Inc., a Washington corporation; Custom Aluminum, Inc., a Washington corporation; Dan Brown Enterprises, Inc., a Washington corporation; Edmonds Roofing Co., Inc., a Washington corporation; My-Lan Co., Inc., a Washington corporation; Pacific Rim Framing Co., Inc., a Washington corporation; Peter Ross, Inc., a Delaware corporation; Professional Homebuilders, LLC, a Washington corporation; and Snyder Roofing of Washington, LLC, a Washington corporation,

          Respondents.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The Pier at Leschi Condominium Owners Association, a Washington nonprofit corporation,
          Respondent,
     v.
Leschi Corporation,

          Appellant.

Marlyn Hawkins
Dean Martin

Stellman Keehnel
Kit Roth






Todd Skoglund
Adil Siddiki
Joseph Grube




Betsy Gillaspy
Daniel Dvorkin/Joel Salmi
Stellman Keehnel


Gregory Turner
William Clement
Steven Wraith
Walter Sinsheimer
Patrick Rothwell
John Dippold
John Kennedy
William Noel


Dean Martin
Marlyn Hawkins


Lori McKown
David Chawes
Mark O'Donnell


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

February 26, 2009

THREE CASES ONLY – ONE IN A.M. – TWO IN P.M.

78287-3 (C/A 55068-3-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Planet Earth Foundation, John Keith Blume, Jr., and Lisa Blume,
          Petitioners,
     v.
Gulf Underwriters Insurance Company and American Business & Personal Insurance, Inc.,
          Respondents.

Franklin Cordell
Christie Snyder


Alan Hughes
Salvador Alejo Mungia, II


1:30 P.M.

80755-8 (C/A 33981-1-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Terry Lee Winterstein,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Susan Baur
James Smith

Anne Mowry Cruser

81116-4 (C/A 58943-1-I & 58944-0-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

In Re the Forfeiture of One: 1970 Chevrolet Chevelle (WLN CV02849).

In Re the Forfeiture of One: 2004 Nissan Sentra
(WLN 9375RL).

Michael Harald Torgesen
Peter Mazzone

Hon. Janice Elizabeth Ellis
Seth Aaron Fine


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

March 10, 2009

THREE CASES ONLY – TWO IN A.M. – ONE IN P.M.

81043-5 (C/A 58658-1-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

In re the Parentage of:
Marnita Frazier (DOB 12-15-93),
          Child,

     and
John Corbin, De Facto Parent,
          Petitioner,
     v.
Patricia Reimen, Biological Mother, Edward Frazier, Biological Father,
          Respondents.





Patricia Novotny
James Shipman

Catherine Wright Smith
Valerie Villacin
Edward Frazier (Pro Se)

80644-6 (C/A 24897-6-III)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Geoffrey S. Ames, M.D.,
          Petitioner,
     v.
Washington State Health Department Medical Quality Health Assurance Commission,
          Respondent.

William Bishin


Hon. Rob McKenna
S. Kim O'Neal
Tracy Bahm


1:30 P.M.

81049-4 (C/A 58454-5-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Kelly L. Shafer,
          Respondent,
     v.
Department of Labor and Industries of the State of Washington,
          Petitioner.

Philip Talmadge
Sidney Tribe
Jennifer Cross-Euteneier
Hon. Rob McKenna
John Wasberg
Jay Geck

82551-3
Original Actions
Motion to Strike Petitioners' Statement of Additional Authority – Passed to the Merits

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

SEIU Healthcare 775NW,
          Petitioner,

     v.
Governor Christine Gregoire,
          Respondent.

Dmitri Iglitzin
  Robert Lavitt
Judith Krebs
Hon. Rob McKenna
  Stewart Johnston
 Maureen Hart


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

March 12, 2009

80873-2 (C/A 35227-3-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Fred Noble and Faith Noble, husband and wife,
          Respondent,
     v.
Safe Harbor Family Preservation Trust, a Washington Trust,
          Petitioner,
     and
Tillicum Beach, Inc., and Eugene and Eleanor Stacy, (Lot 001); Fahsholtz Properties, LLC, (Lot 002); Cyrus and Deborah Riddell, (Lot 003); Russell and Marjorie Sleight, (Lot 004); Paul and Nancy Boschee, (Lot 005); Michael and Joan Kelly, (Lot 007); Peter M. Penna, et ux., (Lot 008); Richard and Tracy Smith, (Lot 009); Irene M. Harvey, (Lot 010); Sharon and James Shelly, (Lot 012); Lawrence and Margaret Knutsen, (Lot 013); Irma I. Hall, (Lot 015); Rita Klosinski and James H. Grimes, (Lot 016); Detlef and Virginia Thibodeaux, (Lot 017); Guy and Kimberly Miltimore, (Lot 018); Denis and Kristie Unkrur, (Lot 019); Thomas and Carole Wiedenhoft, (Lot 020); Leaanne Armstrong, (Lot 021); James and Beverly Noble, (Lot 022); Thomas and Marjorie Jurus, (Lot 900); William and Elezabeth Baluch, (Lot 901); George and Yanshu Hsu, (Lot 902); Bryce and Jenipher Smith, (Lot 904); Eun Jang, (Lot 905),

          Additional Respondents.

Robert Beale



Michael Johns



Robert Wilson-Hoss












80999-2 (C/A 25327-9-III)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Dale Campbell and Tina Fereira,
          Petitioners,
     v.
Ticor Title Insurance Company,
          Respondent.

Richard Wall


Brooke Kuhl
Peter Scott


1:30 P.M.

81020-6 (C/A 34053-4-II)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Mark Patrick Kilgore,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Gerald Horne
Kathleen Proctor

James Dixon

81210-1 (C/A 25524-7-III)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,

     v.
Jason Lee Fry,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Timothy Rasmussen
 John Troberg
 Steven Trinen

William Edelblute


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

March 24, 2009

80925-9 (C/A 59223-8-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

In re the Estate of

Jeanette L. Borghi,

Deceased.

Paulette Peterson

Catherine Wright Smith
Valerie Villacin
Sheila Conlon Ridgway
Robert Ricketts

81525-9 (Grant 03-1-00617-6)

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Robert Bustmante Gonzalez,
          Appellant.

Hon. D. Angus Lee
  Teresa Chen


Jeffrey Goldstein


1:30 P.M.

81107-5 (C/A 24784-8-III & 25007-5-III)
Petition for Review Granted

RESPONDENT’S REQUEST TO REJECT PETITIONER’S REQUEST TO FILE REVISED SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF AND FOR ATTORNEY FEES ASSOCIATED WITH THE FILING OF THE MOTION TO STRIKE ARE PASSED TO THE MERITS

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Teresa Ambach,
          Respondent,

     v.

H. Graeme French, M.D. and Jane Doe French, individually and the marital community composed thereof; Three Forks Orthopaedics, P.C., a Washington professional corporation,
          Petitioners,
Jonathan P. Keeve, M.D.; Northwest Orthopaedic Specialists, P.S., a Washington professional services corporation,
          Defendants.

Kristin Houser
James Hailey
Patrick Fannin
Lindsey Halm

Stephen Haskell
D. Roger Reed





PRO TEM: HUNT, J.P.T

STEPHENS, J. RECUSED

81817-7 (Fed C06-794RSL)

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

Glenn Hutton, et al. and Derivatively on Behalf of Nominal Defendant F5 Networks, Inc.,
          Plaintiffs,
     v.
John McAdam, Karl D. Guelich, Alan J. Higginson, Keith D. Grinstein, Rich Malone, A. Gary Ames, Jeff Pancottine, Edward Eames, Tom Hull, Steve Coburn, Joann M. Reiter, Jeffrey S. Hussey, Steven Goldman, and Brett L. Helsel,
          Defendants,
     and
F5 Networks, Inc.,
          Nominal Defendant.

Kip Shuman
Kirk Mulfinger
John Emerson, Jr.
William Federman/Sara Collier
Benny Goodman/Kevin Green
Travis Downs, III
Daniel Morrissey
Tamara Driscoll
Kevin Green/Travis Downs, III
Daniel Morrissey
Hugh Bangasser/Philip Guess
Richard Kirby
John William Knox/Randy Aliment
George Greer/Lori Phillips
Gregory Hollon/Robert Sulkin
Brian Buckley/Christopher Huck
Jeffrey Coopersmith/Stellman Keehnel/Russell Wuehler/
Kit Roth/Patrick Jordan


9:00 A.M.

Olympia

March 26, 2009

TWO CASES ONLY – TWO IN A.M.

81072-9 (C/A 58176-7-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
Roger Dean Engel,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Daniel Satterberg
James Whisman

Vanessa Mi-jo Lee

81193-8 (C/A 58255-1-I)
Petition for Review Granted

20 MINUTES PER SIDE

State of Washington,
          Respondent,
     v.
David Elvin McCormick,
          Petitioner.

Hon. Janice Ellis
Mary Kathleen Webber

Eric Broman

 

Privacy and Disclaimer NoticesSitemap

© Copyright 2024. Washington State Administrative Office of the Courts.

S3