Skip Page LinksWelcome to Washington State Courts
Courts Home> Court Rules
 
	
                                   RULE 2.4
                   SCOPE OF REVIEW OF A TRIAL COURT DECISION


    (a) Generally. The appellate court will, at the instance of the appellant,
review the decision or parts of the decision designated in the notice of appeal
or, subject to RAP 2.3(e) in the notice for discretionary review and other
decisions in the case as provided in sections (b), (c), (d), and (e). The
appellate court will, at the instance of the respondent, review those acts in
the proceeding below which if repeated on remand would constitute error
prejudicial to respondent. The appellate court will grant a respondent
affirmative relief by modifying the decision which is the subject matter of the
review only (1) if the respondent also seeks review of the decision by the
timely filing of a notice of appeal or a notice of discretionary review, or (2)
if demanded by the necessities of the case.

    (b) Order or Ruling Not Designated in Notice. The appellate court will
review a trial court order or ruling not designated in the notice, including an
appealable order, if (1) the order or ruling prejudicially affects the decision
designated in the notice, and (2) the order is entered, or the ruling is made,
before the appellate court accepts review.  A timely notice of appeal of a
trial court decision relating to attorney fees and costs does not bring up for
review a decision previously entered in the action that is otherwise appealable
under rule 2.2(a) unless a timely notice of appeal has been filed to seek
review of the previous decision.

    (c) Final Judgment Not Designated in Notice. Except as provided in rule
2.4(b), the appellate court will review a final judgment not designated in the
notice only if the notice designates an order deciding a timely post-trial
motion based on (1) CR 50(b) (judgment as a matter of law), (2) CR 52(b)
(amendment of findings), (3) CR 59 (reconsideration, new trial, and amendment
of judgments), (4) CrR 7.4 (arrest of judgment), or (5) CrR 7.5 (new trial).

    (d) Order Deciding Alternative Post-trial Motions in Civil Case. An appeal
from the judgment granted on a motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict
brings up for review the ruling of the trial court on a motion for new trial.
If the appellate court reverses the judgment notwithstanding the verdict, the
appellate court will review the ruling on the motion for a new trial.

    (e) Order Deciding Alternative Post-trial Motions in Criminal Case. An
appeal from an order granting a motion in arrest of judgment brings up for
review the ruling of the trial court on a motion for new trial. If the
appellate court reverses the order granting the motion in arrest of judgment,
the appellate court will review the ruling on a motion for new trial.

    (f) Decisions on Certain Motions Not Designated in Notice. An appeal from a
final judgment brings up for review the ruling of the trial court on an order
deciding a timely motion based on (1) CR 50(b) (judgment as a matter of law),
(2) CR 52(b) (amendment of findings), (3) CR 59 (reconsideration, new trial,
and amendment of judgments), (4) CrR 7.4 (arrest of judgment), or (5) CrR 7.5
(new trial).

    (g) Award of Attorney Fees. An appeal from a decision on the merits of a
case brings up for review an award of attorney fees entered after the appellate
court accepts review of the decision on the merits.


[Amended December 5, 2002; amended effective September 1, 2010]
	

Click here to view in a PDF.

 
 
Courts | Organizations | News | Opinions | Rules | Forms | Directory | Library 
Back to Top | Privacy and Disclaimer Notices