|
Note: This opinion has been revised for publication. To find the official opinion go the Washington State Judicial Opinions Website
View the Slip Opinion(s) Filed for this Case.
Tip: Opinions open faster in Edge, Chrome, and FireFox once the FireFox PDF reader has been disabled.
View a Printer Friendly Version of this Opinion Information Sheet.
Supreme Court of the State of Washington
Opinion Information Sheet
Docket Number: |
99374-2 |
Title of Case: |
State v. M.Y.G. |
File Date: |
05/19/2022 |
Oral Argument Date: |
09/21/2021 |
SOURCE OF APPEAL
----------------
Appeal from Spokane County Superior Court |
Docket No: | 19-8-00616-8 |
Judgment or order under review |
Date filed: | 12/04/2019 |
Judge signing: | Honorable Rachelle E. Anderson |
JUSTICES
--------
Steven C. González | Dissent in part Author | Author of concurrence in part, dissent in result. |
Charles W. Johnson | Signed Lead Opinion | |
Barbara A. Madsen | Signed Dissent in part | Signed concurrence in part, dissent in result (González). |
Susan Owens | Lead Opinion Author | |
Debra L. Stephens | Signed Lead Opinion | |
Sheryl Gordon McCloud | Signed Dissent in part | Signed concurrence in part, dissent in result (González). |
Mary I. Yu | Signed Dissent in part | Signed concurrence in part, dissent in part (Whitener). |
Raquel Montoya-Lewis | Signed Dissent in part | Signed concurrence in part, dissent in part (Whitener). |
G. Helen Whitener | Dissent in part Author | Author of concurrence in part, dissent in part. |
COUNSEL OF RECORD
-----------------
Counsel for Petitioner(s) |
| Andrea Burkhart |
| Two Arrows, PLLC |
| 8220 W. Gage Blvd. #789 |
| Kennewick, WA, 99336-8113 |
|
| Nancy P. Collins |
| Washington Appellate Project |
| 1511 3rd Ave. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98101-3647 |
Counsel for Respondent(s) |
| Larry D. Steinmetz |
| Office of Spokane County Prosecuting Attorney |
| 1100 W. Mallon Ave. |
| Spokane, WA, 99260-2043 |
|
| Jason Moscowitz |
| Office of Spokane County Prosecuting Attorney |
| 1100 W. Mallon Ave. |
| Spokane, WA, 99260-2043 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of King County Department of Public Defense |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of American Civil Liberties Union of WA |
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Washington Defender Association |
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Asian Counseling and Referral Service |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Center for Children and Youth Justice |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Choose 180 |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Collective Justice |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Community Passageways |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Council On American Islamic Relations Washington Chapter |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Electronic Frontier Foundation |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Juvenile Law Center |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste.200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Kent Black Action Commission |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of La Resistencia |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of League of Education Voters |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Legal Counsel for Youth and Children |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Look2justice |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Mockingbird Society |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Mothers for Police Accountability |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| Po Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Oneamerica |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Real Change |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Teamchild |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
Amicus Curiae on behalf of Urban League of Metropolitan Seattle |
| Katherine Elizabeth Hurley |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| La Rond Baker |
| King County Department of Public Defense |
| 710 2nd Ave. Ste. 200 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-1703 |
|
| Julia Mizutani |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Nancy Lynn Talner |
| ACLU-WA |
| P. O. Box 2728 |
| Seattle, WA, 98111-2728 |
|
| Cindy Arends Elsberry |
| Washington Defender Association |
| 110 Prefontaine Pl. S. Ste. 610 |
| Seattle, WA, 98104-2626 |
View the Slip Opinion(s) Filed for this Case.
For the official opinion go the Washington State Judicial Opinions Website
View a Printer Friendly Version of this Opinion Information Sheet.
|
|