Petitions for Review
July 8, 2008

The following are the results of the petitions for review considered by a department of the Supreme Court on July 8, 2008.

Department One

July 8, 2008
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

1 

32499-7-II
33798-3-II

80516-4

State v. Fleming
Denied

2 

36251-1-II

80767-1

State v. Jensen
Denied

3 

25639-1-III

80775-2

State v. Munds
Denied

4 

23870-9-III
23895-4-III

80781-7

In re Pers. Restraint of Johnson;
State v. Johnson
Denied

5 

57898-7-I

80786-8

State v. Mefi
Continued to September 3, 2008, Department One

6 

57850-2-I

80787-6

Jones v. State
Continued to September 4, 2008, En Banc Conference

7 

58241-1-I

80788-4

State v. Pham
Denied

8 

58941-5-I

80789-2

Save Sea Lawn Acres Ass’n v. Mercer
Denied

9 

57584-8-I

80791-4

State v. Gilbert
Denied

10 

57669-1-I

80792-2

State v. Tesfaye
Deny both Tesfaye’s petition and State’s petition

11 

57851-1-I

80795-7

Lafley v. Seadrunar Recycling, L.L.C.
Denied

12 

33734-7-II
35257-5-II

80798-1

State v. Mayfield
Denied

13 

34332-1-II &
35299-1-II

80800-7

State v. Baxley
Denied

14 

59339-1-I

80803-1

Cherrington v. Cingular Wireless, Inc.
Denied

15 

58245-3-I

80827-9

Bostwick v. Ballard Marine, Inc.
Denied

16 

56935-0-I

80850-3

State v. Pugh
Grant Pugh’s petition and deny State’s cross petition

17 

57401-9-I

80854-6

State v. Kyzar
Denied

18 

58572-0-I

80857-1

State v. Carlson
Denied

19 

56504-4-I

80858-9

State v. McKee
Denied

20 

57652-6-I

80860-1

State v. Burch
Denied

21 

58337-9-I

80870-8

State v. Bartolo-Hernandez
Denied

22 

35227-3-II

80873-2

Noble v. Safe Harbor Family Pres. Trust
Granted

23 

35383-1-II

80878-3

Abbey Road Group, LLC v. City of Bonney Lake
Granted

24 

35508-6-II

80880-5

State v. Valdez
Denied

25 

36057-8-II

80883-0

Northwest Gas Ass’n v. Wash. Util. & Transp. Comm’n
Denied

26 

57963-1-I

80884-8

State v. Hasbrouck
Denied

27 

34493-9-II

80890-2

State v. Parkison
Denied

28 

35630-9-II

80895-3

State v. Smith
Denied

29 

25329-5-III

80900-3

Amiri v. Cent. Wash. Family Med.
Denied

30 

25861-1-III

80901-1

In re Marriage of Magnuson
Denied

31 

36132-9-II

80903-8

Foxworthy v. Puyallup Tribe of Indians Ass’n
Continued to September 4, 2008, En Banc Conference

32 

35162-5-II

80904-6

State v. Quiroz
Denied

33 

58649-1-I

80915-1

Lungu v. Dep’t of Licensing
Denied

34 

33859-9-II

80961-5

State v. Hudson
Continued to September 3, 2008, Department One Calendar

35 

25399-6-III

80964-0

State v. Tesch
Denied

36 

59061-8-I

81398-1

In re Marriage of Katare
Denied

37 

53247-2-I
53246-4-I
53248-1-I

76874-9

State v. Webster
Granted and remanded to Court of Appeals in light of Hughes & Hall

38 

54246-0-I

77912-1

State v. Mezquia
Denied

39 

54975-8-I

78876-6

State v. Graham
Granted only on issue of firearm enhancement and consolidated with State v. Ruth #79074-4

40 

56318-1-I

79074-4

State v. Ruth
Granted and consolidated with State v. Graham #78876-6
(other pending motions are all denied)

41 

55871-4-I

79905-9

State v. Ryan
Denied

42 

56048-4-I

80021-9

State v. Tu
Denied

43 

35331-8-II

80876-7

State v. Korum
Continued to September 4, 2008, En Banc Conference

44 

54933-2-1

78101-0

State v. Nguyen
Continued to September 4, 2008, En Banc Conference

45 

34240-5-II

79940-7

State v. Veth
Denied

46 

34628-1-II

80443-5

State v. Blanks
Denied

47 

35258-3-II

80562-8

State v. Saunders
Denied

48 

34570-6-II

80748-5

State v. Ortiz-Santiago
Denied

49 

55686-0-I

80777-9

State v. Sasse
Denied

50 

57951-7-I

80785-0

State v. Dillon
Denied

51 

58089-2-I

80852-0

State v. Grove
Denied

52 

56607-5-I
56673-3-I

80853-8

State v. Hambling
Denied

53 

57923-1-I

80855-4

State v. Payne
Deferred pending Daniels #76802-1

54 

57053-6-I

80856-2

State v. Bowman
Denied

55 

57460-4-I

80862-7

State v. Mayberry
Denied

56 

34627-3-II

80877-5

State v. Peterson
Denied

57 

58837-1-I

80886-4

State v. Guerrero-Melchor
Denied

58 

34093-3-II
34907-8-II

80894-5

State v. Schwab;
In re Pers. Restraint of Schwab
Continued to September 3, 2008, Department One Calendar

59 

34844-6-II
34850-1-II
34854-3-II

80896-1

State v. Romero
Denied

60 

25614-6-III

80965-8

State v. Duckett
Deferred pending Strode & Momah # 80849-0 & 81096-6

61 

25421-6-III

80946-1

State v. Cruz
Deferred pending Strode & Momah # 80849-0 & 81096-6


MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE PETITION FOR
REVIEW & PETITION FOR REVIEW
 

5 

57560-1-I

80986-1

Richardson v. Dep’t of Labor & Industries
Motion for extension of time to file petition for review is granted and the petition for review is denied

 

Department Two

July 8, 2008
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

1 

58514-2-I

80885-6

Matthews v. State
Denied

2 

55842-1-I

80916-0

Reinertsen v. Rygg
Petitioner’s petition for review, motion to sanctions, motion for judicial estopel and motion to strike Respondents’ answer are all denied.

3 

58741-2-I

80917-8

In re Marriage of Ellis
Petition for review denied; Respondent Samantha’s attorney fee request granted.

4 

34630-3-II

80922-4

Magana v. Hyundai Motor Am.
Continued to September 4, 2008, En Banc Conference

5 

59223-8-I

80925-9

In re the Estate of Borghi
Granted

6 

57569-4-I

80926-7

State v. Phadnis
Denied

7 

57987-8-I

80927-5

Nelson v. Schnautz
Denied

8 

59313-7-I

80928-3

State v. Shultz
Denied

9 

59333-1-I

80929-1

King County v. Seawest Inv. Assocs.
Denied

10 

57958-4-I

80930-5

Westmark Dev. Corp. v. City of Burien
Denied

11 

35743-7-II

80932-1

State v. Whitmire
Denied

12 

58120-1-I

80935-6

State v. Donaldson
Denied

13 

56591-5-I

80937-2

Red Oaks Condo. Owners Ass’n v. Am. States Ins. Co.
Petition for review granted and the cross appeal limited to applicability of faulty workmanship exclusion is granted.

14 

56954-6-I

80938-1

In re Marriage of Rockwell
Petition for review denied; Carmen’s attorney fee request is granted.

15 

58423-5-I
58890-7-I

80939-9

State v. McCoy
Denied

16 

25255-8-III

80941-1

State v. Garvin
Pending

17 

34397-5-II

80953-4

State v. Taylor
Denied

18 

24269-2-III

80410-9

State v. Jefferson
Denied

19 

33379-1-II

80973-9

Sharbono v. Universal Underwriters Ins. Co.
Petitions for review denied; Grant Sharbono’s motion to strike Universal’s reply to answer.

20 

57328-4-I

81003-6

Cambridge Townhomes, LLC v. Pac. Star Roofing, Inc.
Petitions for review granted; Grant Utley’s motion to intervene or accept as amicus; motion to strike replies is granted.

21 

35733-0-II

81022-2

DOT Foods, Inc. v. Dep’t of Revenue
Granted

22 

34626-5-II

81026-5

In re Marriage of Bort
Denied

23 

57853-7-I

81034-6

Chandler v. State Ins. Comm’r
Denied

24 

35189-7-II

81038-9

State v. Vance
Denied

25 

34939-6-II

81039-7

State v. Vessey
Denied

26 

58658-1-I

81043-5

In re Parentage of Frazier
Granted

27 

58454-5-I

81049-4

Shafer v. Dep’t of Labor & Indus.
Petition for review filed by Department of L&I is granted and Shafer’s issue is denied.

28 

57496-5-I

81056-7

State v. Calderon
Denied

29 

58465-1-I

81063-0

State v. Teall
Denied

30 

25569-7-III

81071-1

State v. Kramer
Granted

31 

58176-7-I

81072-9

State v. Engel
Granted

32 

59029-4-I

81073-7

State v. Landry
Denied

33 

57875-8-I

81074-5

State v. Holmes
Denied

34 

56437-4-I

81075-3

State v. Zebe
Denied

35 

59213-1-I

81076-1

Crinks v. Torres

– STRICKEN (Dismissed pursuant to parties’ agreed motion)

36 

58672-6-I

81077-0

State v. Agee
Denied

37 

58979-2-I

81078-8

Johnson v. King County Library Sys.
Denied

38 

25258-2-III

81084-2

In re the Partnership of Rhone & Butcher
Denied

39 

59053-7-I
59251-3-I

81088-5

Edenholm v. Flytrap Network Sec., Inc.
Denied

40 

31283-2-II

77995-3

Clallam County v. W. Wash. Growth Mgmt. Hearings Bd.
Denied

41 

23023-6-III

78611-9

State v. Williams-Walker
Pending

42 

55350-0-I

79020-5

State v. Erickson
Pending

43 

33373-2-II

79509-6

State v. Sibert
Pending

44 

22315-9-III

79689-1

State v. Jones
Pending

45 

22336-1-III

80088-0

State v. Graham
Pending

46 

55443-3-I

79349-2

State v. Nguyen
Petition for review denied, motion to file overlength motion is granted and motion to return to trial court is denied.

47 

24410-5-III

80185-1

State v. Bailey
Petition for review and motion to consolidate with State v. Nguyen is denied.

48 

56439-1-I

79946-6

State v. Brassy-Apodaca
Denied

49 

57762-0-I

80471-1

State v. Hiatt
Denied

50 

25037-7-III

80485-1

State v. Stratton
Denied

51 

25389-9-III

80666-7

State v. Campbell
Denied

52 

35116-1-II

80931-3

State v. Heslen
Denied

53 

25036-9-III

80942-9

State v. Crook
Denied

54 

25798-3-III

80950-0

State v. Duran
Denied

55 

58044-2-I

81002-8

Navarre v. DSHS
Denied

56 

25395-3-III

81027-3

State v. Schimanskey
Denied

57 

52371-6-I

81053-2

State v. Opel
Denied

58 

57042-1-I

81055-9

State v. Miller
Denied

59 

59497-4-I

81080-0

Kim v. City of Federal Way
Petition for review is denied; motion for sanctions is denied.

60 

59119-3-I

81148-2

Crawford v. Woodward
Denied

61 

36173-6-II

81559-3

State v. Selfridge
Petition for review and motion for remand to trial court is denied.

 

  

Privacy and Disclaimer Notices Sitemap

© Copyright 2025. Washington State Administrative Office of the Courts.

S3