Petitions for Review
July 7, 2009

The following are the results of Petitions for Review considered by a Department One of the Supreme Court on July 7, 2009.

Department One

July 7, 2009
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

1 

59458-3-I

82359-6

State v. Habtemariam
Deny petition for review;deny motion to appoint counsel

2 

60211-0-I

82667-6

Salvini v. Ski Lifts, Inc. d/b/a The Summit at Snoqualmie
Denied

3 

26224-3-III

82678-1

State v. Senior Asset Pres. Servs.
Denied

4 

36245-7-II

82690-1

Ameriquest Mortgage Co. v. Att’y Gen.
Granted on federal preemption issue only

5 

37370-0-II

82693-5

Allstate Ins. Co. v. Thornton
Denied

6 

23247-6-III

82699-4

State v. Bainard
Granted

7 

58449-9-I

82715-0

State v. Alphonse
Denied

8 

60042-7-I

82718-4

State v. Backman
Continued to September 10, 2009, En Banc Conference

9 

60341-8-I

82719-2

In re Marriage of Waters
Denied

10 

61414-2-I

82721-4

Ross v. Bennett
Denied

11 

59429-0-I

82723-1

In re Marriage of Wieldraayer
Denied

12 

61015-5-I

82726-5

Barton v. State
Denied

13 

60554-2-I

82728-1

Overlake Hosp. Ass’n & Overlake Hosp. Med. Ctr. v. State Dep’t of Health
Granted

14 

36029-2-II
consol. w/ 36115-9-II

82731-1

State v. Sanchez;
State v. Valencia Sanchez
Granted

15 

26567-6-III

82732-0

In re Det. of C. M.
Denied

16 

26540-4-III

82735-4

State v. Newland
Denied

17 

60265-9-I

82736-2

State v. Monday
Granted on issue of whether prosecutorial misconduct deprived the defendant of a fair trial and whether imposition of firearms enhancements voided the defendant’s jury trial rights & Williams-Walker issues

18 

61021-0-I

82739-7

Yow v. State Dep’t of Health
Deny petition for review; Grant Department of Health’s motion to strike appendix F from Dirk Yow's petition for review.

19 

36430-1-II

82743-5

State v. Scarpa
Continued to September 10, 2009, En Banc Conference

20 

36804-8-II

82744-3

State v. Hirschfelder
Granted

21 

36952-4-II

82750-8

State v. Draxinger
Denied

22 

36739-4-II

82822-9

State v. C.A.E.
Denied

23 

60528-3-I

83024-0

Bellevue Sch. Dist. v. E.S.
Grant petition for review; deny motion for accelerated review

24 

35411-0-II

82823-7

Dominguez v. City of Tacoma
Denied

25 

59666-7-I

82568-8

In re Det. of West
Continued to September 10, 2009, En Banc Conference

26 

59358-7-I

81616-6

State v. Loy
Granted and remanded to the Court of Appeals to reconsider in light of Mendoza (165 Wn.2d 913)

27 

57613-5-I

81215-2

State v Jolliffe
Continued to September 8, 2009, Department One

28 

58659-9-I

81265-9

State v. McGee
Continued to September 8, 2009, Department One

29 

37575-3-II

82658-7

State v. Thomas
Denied

30 

26502-1-III

82682-0

State v. Miller
Denied

31 

61124-1-I

82720-6

State v. Hill
Deferred penting Brooks #80704-3

32 

61058-9-I

82722-2

State v. Gonzales
Deferred penting Brooks #80704-3

33 

60704-9-I

82724-9

State v. Kaizuka
Denied

34 

61007-4-I

82737-1

In re Guardianship of Watson
Deny Haan’s petition for review; grant State’s motion to strike reply & addendum; deny State’s request for sanctions; deny Haan’s motion to partially strike State’s answer or to state consideration of petition for review

35 

36582-1-II

82740-1

State v. Dunlap
Denied

36 

60198-9-I

82748-6

State v. Wells
Denied

37 

37390-4-II

82755-9

State v. Goins
Denied

38 

36983-4-II

82815-6

State v. Rorie
Denied

MOTIONS

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

22 

37604-1-II

82955-1

State v. Simmet
Grant motion for extension of time; deny petition for review

23 

36572-3-II

83004-5

Fawn Lake Maint. Comm’n v. Abers
Grant motion for extension of time; deny petition for review.  The request for attorney fees is denied

 

Department Two

July 7, 2009
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

1 

60923-8-I

82687-1

Humphrey Indus. LTD v. Clay St. Assocs. LLC

Granted

2 

61408-8-I

82761-3

State v. Hemler

Denied

3 

61204-2-I

82763-0

State v. Sou

Denied

4 

60398-1-I

82764-8

State v. Sims

Denied

5 

60342-6-I

82766-4

State v. Holloway

Denied

6 

60999-8-I

82767-2

State v. Freeburg

Denied

7 

60227-6-I

82772-9

State v. Archie

Denied

8 

61467-3-I

82775-3

Morris v. Swedish Health Servs. d/b/a Swedish Med. Ctr.

Deferred pending Putman #80888-1

9 

26985-0-III

82789-3

Allen v. Canterbury

Denied

10 

37587-7-II

82790-7

Rutledge v. Beck

Denied

11 

60669-7-I

82804-1

State v. Lee

Denied

12 

61347-2-I

82809-1

State v. Pratt, aka Peters

Deny petition for review and deny Petitioner’s motion for waiver of rules and extension of time to file supplemental grounds to the Supreme Court of Washington

13 

60477-5-I

82810-5

Simpson v. New Stevens, LLC, d/b/a Stevens Pass

Denied

14 

61311-1-I

82811-3

State v. Johnson

Denied

15 

61419-3-I

82812-1

Carlile v. Harbour Homes, Inc., f/k/a Geonerco, Inc.

Grant only on Homeowners’ issue of economic loss & assignment of warranty

16 

60836-3-I

82813-0

Parmelee v. Clarke

Denied

17 

60608-5-I

82917-9

State v. Velasquez

Denied

18 

60711-1-I

82919-5

In re Marriage of Spring

Denied

19 

61409-6-I

82921-7

State v. Larue

Denied

20 

60423-6-I

82925-0

State v. Diaz-Flores

Denied

21 

57691-7-I

80716-7

State v. Weaver

Granted only on offender score issue and remanded to the Court of Appeals to reconsider in light of Mendoza 165 Wn.2d 913

22 

57684-4-I

81308-6

State v. Lucero

Granted only on offender score issue and remanded to the Court of Appeals to reconsider in light of Mendoza 165 Wn.2d 913

23 

36855-2-II

82703-6

State v. Grubbs, aka Grabbs

Denied

24 

60727-8-I

82768-1

State v. Greer

Denied

25 

60852-5-I

82770-2

State v. Arnold

Denied

26 

60622-1-I

82771-1

Chen v. Isola

Deferred pending Waples #82142-9

27 

60049-4-I

82776-1

State v. Johnson

Denied

28 

37497-8-II

82778-8

Hyers v. Scannell

Denied

29 

26606-1-III

82788-5

State v. Risley

Denied

30 

36470-1-II
consol. w/ 36536-7-II

82797-4

State v. Danielson;
State v. Brewer

Denied

31 

61338-3-I

82798-2

State v. Steel

Denied

32 

36625-8-II

82802-4

State v. Wise

Deferred pending Momah #81096-6 & Strode #80849-0

33 

60604-2-I

82805-9

State v. Vo

Denied

34 

60457-1-I

82806-7

State v. Tinsley

Denied

35 

60336-1-I

82807-5

State v. Huynh

Deferred pending Williams-Walker #78611-9

36 

60298-5-I

82808-3

State v. Archie

Denied

37 

61069-4-I

82918-7

State v. Ventura

Deferred pending Bunker #81921-2

MOTION

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

23 

26589-7-II

83064-9

Mack v. Armstrong
Deny motion for extension of time; deny Respondent’s request for attorney fees?

  

Privacy and Disclaimer Notices Sitemap

© Copyright 2025. Washington State Administrative Office of the Courts.

S5