Petitions for Review
September 3, 2008

The following are the results of the petitions for review considered by a department of the Supreme Court on September 3, 2008.

Department One

September 3, 2008
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

1 

24784-8-III
25007-5-III

81107-5

Ambach v. French
Granted

2 

33257-4-II

81112-1

State v. Elliott
Denied

3 

58943-1-I
58944-0-I

81116-4

In the Matter of the 1970 Chevrolet;
In the Matter of the 2004 Nissan
Granted

4 

57416-7-I
58021-3-I

81122-9

Doe v. Corp. of the President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints
Denied

5 

34147-6-II

81124-5

State v. Carney
Denied

6 

33954-4-II

81125-3

In re Custody of Radford
Denied

7 

58150-3-I

81138-5

Britannia Holdings Ltd. v. Greer
Deny petition for review; deny Respondent’s request for attorney fees.

8 

58975-0-I

81139-3

Happy Bunch, LLC v. Grandview North, LLC
Denied

9 

58844-3-I

81140-7

State v. Laconte
Denied

10 

57326-8-I

81141-5

Clear Channel Outdoor, Inc. v. Schrem P’ship
Deny petition for review; grant Respondent’s  attorney fee request.

11 

58574-6-I

81144-0

In re Detention of Snively
Denied

12 

58897-4-I

81147-4

State v. Palanchuk
Denied

13 

59359-5-I

81150-4

Popescu v. Univ. of Wash.
Denied

14 

35795-0-II

81153-9

State v. Smith
Denied

15 

35433-1-II

81158-0

State v. Richey
Denied

16 

58302-6-I

81161-0

Ballard v. Dep’t of Health
Denied

17 

32729-5-II

81164-4

State v. Kyllo
Continued to October 2, 2008, En Banc Conference

18 

58831-1-I

81195-4

Armantrout v. Carlson, M.D.
Continued to October 2, 2008, En Banc Conference

19 

24820-8-III

81230-6

In re Detention of Duncan
Continued to October 2, 2008, En Banc Conference

20 

25470-4-III

81236-5

State v. A.N.J.
Continued to October 1, 2008, Department I.  Respondent is directed to file an answer to the petition for review.

21 

34802-1-II

81243-8

State v. Dow
Granted

22 

35297-4-II

81246-2

In re Marriage of Mullan
Deny petition for review; Deny issue raised by Merceil; deny Merceil’s request for attorney fees; grant Frederick’s attorney fee request.

23 

35292-3-II

81251-9

State v. Brooks
Denied

24 

35352-1-II

81252-7

McCormick v. Estvold
Deny petition for review; grant Respondent’s attorney fee request.

25 

58544-4-I

81253-5

Gregoire v. City of Oak Harbor
Petition for review granted only on the issue as to the jury instruction as to contributing negligence and assumption of risk.

26 

25161-6-III

81257-8

Fitzpatrick v. Okanogan County
Granted

27 

59129-1-I

81260-8

State v. Idland
Denied

28 

57942-8-I

81261-6

State v. Nguyen
Continued to October 2, 2008, En Banc Conference

29 

25518-2-III

81266-7

English v. Casselberry
Deny petition for review; deny Respondent’s request for attorney fees.

30 

24621-3-III

81269-1

State v. Doney
Continued to October 2, 2008, En Banc Conference

31 

23946-2-III

81270-5

State v. Hughes
Granted

32 

25316-3-III
25317-1-III

81271-3

City of Spokane v. Rothwell;
City of Spokane v. Smith
Granted

33 

25606-5-III

81272-1

State v. Mills
Denied

34 

58710-2-I

81279-9

City of Seattle v. Winebrenner
Granted and consolidated with 81280-2.

35 

58336-1-I

81280-2

City of Seattle v. Quezada
Granted and consolidated under 81279-9

36 

57898-7-I

80786-8

State v. Mefi
Denied

37 

33859-9-II

80961-5

State v. Hudson
Deferred pending State v. Powell, # 80496-6

38 

34093-3-II
34907-8-II

80894-5

State v. Schwab;
In re Pers. Restraint of Schwab
Denied

39 

59690-0-I

81121-1

Kasahara v. Richardson
Deny petition for review; deny motion to strike answer; deny motions for sanctions and deny injunctive relief.

40 

35215-0-II

81123-7

State v. Grayson
Denied

41 

35230-3-II

81126-1

State v. Yocupicio-Melendez
Denied

42 

25873-4-III

81154-7

State v. Woods
Denied

43 

36167-1-II

81157-1

State v. R.C.
Denied

44 

25335-0-III

81183-1

State v. Hedahl
Denied

45 

25434-8-III

81220-9

In re Guardianship of Riddle
Denied

46

35434-9-II
35698-8-II

81234-9

Young v. DSHS
Deny petition for review and all other motions filed by the Petitioner.

47

35524-8-II

81235-7

State v. Curry
Denied

48

24530-6-III
(cons. w/
24216-1-III &
25291-4-III)

81258-6

In re Estate of Jones;
Estate of Jones
Deny petition for review; grant Respondent’s request for attorney fees.

49

54560-4-I

81263-2

State v. Dillon
Denied

50

58475-8-I

81264-1

State v. Lopez
Denied

51

58659-9-I

81265-9

State v. McGee
Deferred pending Wright #78465-5.

52

25621-9-III

81267-5

State v. Zielke
Denied

53

25765-7-III
25839-4-III

81273-0

State v. Wilson;
In re PRP of Wilson
Denied

MOTIONS/PETITIONS


23 

36750-5-II

81612-3

Thurston County v. Sager
Motion for extension of time to file untimely petition for review is denied; all other motions filed by Petitioner are also denied.

26 

59275-1-I

81714-6

Ducote v. Dep’t of Soc. & Health Servs.
Motion for extension of time to file petition for review is granted; petition for review is granted.

Department Two

September 3, 2008
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

1 

58545-2-I

81070-2

Pan Abode Homes, Inc. v. Abdulfhafid
Denied

2 

60708-1-I

81186-5

In re Det. of Ticeson
Denied

3 

25628-6-III

81228-4

State v. Gonzalez
Denied

4 

35404-7-II

81231-4

Melnikoff v. Wash. State Patrol
Denied

5 

35150-1-II

81232-2

Hoskins v. Reich
Denied

6 

58815-0-I
58983-1-I
59319-6-I

81262-4

In re Marriage of Garth & Brown
Deny petition for review; deny Respondent’s request for attorney fees.

7 

57684-4-I

81308-6

State v. Lucero
Deferred pending #80477-0 - State v. Mendoza and #80553-9 - State v. Henderson.

8 

57827-8-I

81310-8

State v. Schaller
Denied

9 

58577-1-I

81311-6

Thompson v. Hanson
Continued to October 1, 2008, Department Two

10 

58204-6-I

81313-2

Weinberg v. George Brookings dba Brookings Land Dev.
Deny petition for review; grant Respondent’s request for attorney fees.

11 

59626-8-I

81314-1

State v. Webb
Granted

12 

58915-6-I

81323-0

State v. Bell
Denied

13 

58463-4-I

81325-6

State v. Lopez
Denied

14 

58397-2-I

81326-4

State v. Taggart
Denied

15 

24935-2-III

81327-2

State v. Blackmon
Denied

16 

58932-6-I

81328-1

In re Estate of Kissinger
Petition for review granted; review also granted of issue raised in answer to the petition for review.

17 

25882-3-III

81329-9

State v. Jessen
Denied

18 

35240-1-II

81345-1

State v. Classen
Denied

19 

35020-3-II

81346-9

State v. Smith (Thomas)
Denied

20 

35019-0-II

81347-7

State v. Ra
Denied

21 

34911-6-II

81348-5

State v. Eaton
Granted

22 

35490-0-II

81352-3

State v. Frazier
Denied

23 

35366-1-II
35574-4-II

81353-1

State v. Smith;
State v. Peterson
Denied

24 

57821-9-I
cons. w/57321-7-1
linked w/57320-9-I

81356-6

Faust v. Albertson
Continued to October 1, 2008, Department Two

25 

60291-8-I

81358-2

Siewert v. Dep’t of Health
Denied

26 

58762-5-I

81373-6

State v. Newlun
Deferred pending Alvarado #81069-9.

27 

35237-1-II

81374-4

State v. Kenyon
Granted

28 

35439-0-II

81375-2

State v. Wheeler
Denied

29 

35548-5-II

81378-7

In re Marriage of Angelo;
Angelo v. Angelo
Deny petition for review; deny Respondents’ request for attorney fees and expenses.

30 

59526-1-I

81383-3

Rodriguez v. Windermere Real Estate/Wall St., Inc.
Denied

31 

23972-1-III

81403-1

State v. Suarez
Denied

32 

24870-4-III

81441-4

State v. Castillo
Denied

33 

35396-2-II

81443-1

Nelson Alaska Seafoods, Inc. v. Dep’t of Revenue
Denied

34 

35359-8-II

81448-1

State v. Pearson
Deny petition for review; deny Respondent’s motion to stay case pending State v. Ramos #77347-5.

35 

35608-2-II

81452-0

Storedahl Props., L.L.C. v. Clark County
Denied

36 

36889-7-II

81506-2

All Real Estate Solutions, Inc. v. Dep’t of L&I; Mello
Deny petition for review; deny Petitioner's motion to stay proceedings before the Board of Industrial Appeals.

37 

58666-1-I

81093-1

State v. Baca
Denied

38 

25559-0-III

81229-2

State v. Clemens
Denied

39 

25813-1-III

81241-1

State v. Gardner
Denied

40 

56208-8-I

81274-8

Cacho v. Dep’t of Labor & Indus.
Denied

41 

58698-0-I

81275-6

State v. Davis
Deny petition for review; deny Petitioner’s motion for indigence.  Special petition for writ of habeas corpus filed by petitioner is transferred to the Court of Appeals for determination as a personal restraint petition.

42 

25515-8-III

81330-2

State v. Yaeger
Denied

43 

35340-7-II

81350-7

State v. Velcota
Denied

44 

34887-0-II

81359-1

State v. Smith (John)
Denied

45 

34997-3-II

81370-1

State v. Glasmann
Denied

46 

58608-4-I

81394-9

Sanchez-Naser v. Employment Sec. Dep’t
Denied

47 

25598-1-III

81439-2

State v. Garner
Denied

48 

24879-8-III

81444-9

State v. Voss
Denied

49 

35778-0-II

81451-1

Granton v. Lottery Comm’n
Denied

50 

57240-7-I

81548-8

In re Det. of Johnson
Denied

 

MOTIONS/PETITIONS

25 

58611-4-I

81584-4

Cutter v. McLaren
Motion for extension to file petition for review granted; petition for review denied; Respondent’s request for attorney fees is granted.

 

 

  

Privacy and Disclaimer Notices Sitemap

© Copyright 2025. Washington State Administrative Office of the Courts.

S5