Petitions for Review
November 4, 2009

 The following are the results of the petitions for review considered by a department of the Supreme Court on November 4, 2009.

Department One

November 4, 2009
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

1

35269-9-II
consol. w/ 35792-5-II & 35799-2-II

83034-7

State v. Asaeli
Deny both petitions for review (State and Asaeli)

2

37098-1-II

83060-6

In re Marriage of Meredith
Both petitions for review are denied. Both motions for extension of time are granted. Respondent’s motion to dismiss is denied. Petitioner’s motion to strike is denied.

3

61921-7-I

83161-1

Melin-Schilling v. Imm
Denied

4

61959-4-I

83166-1

Sievert v. City of Seattle
Denied

5

61462-2-I

83169-6

State v. Mitchell
Granted only on issue of dependant person

6

60947-5-I

83171-8

State v. Lyons
Denied

7

37272-0-II

83233-1

Save Columbia CU Comm. v. Columbia Cmty. Credit Union
Denied

8

26862-4-III

83240-4

Stoller v. State
Denied

9

60474-1-I

83244-7

State v. Ervin
Granted

10

61606-4-I

83246-3

Sacotte Constr., Inc. v. Taluswood Townhomes, LLC, a/k/a Mosaic Homes USA Ltd., f/k/a Coast Guard Site, LLC
Deferred pending Broom v. Morgan Stanley DW, Inc. #82311-1

11

62377-0-I

83250-1

Shim v. City of Tukwila
Denied

12

61095-3-I

83252-8

State v. Flores, aka Escobedo-Flores
Denied

13

59723-0-I

83254-4

State v. Sorto
Denied

14

62555-1-I

83255-2

Spark Networks, PLC f/k/a MATCHNET, PLC v. Knedlik
Denied

15

37374-2-II

83256-1

State v. Anene
Continued to December 3, 2009, En Banc Conference

16

37504-4-II

83261-7

State v. O’Connor
Granted and remanded to the Court of Appeals in light of Arizona v. Gant

17

61034-1-I

83262-5

In re Det. of Liptrap
Denied

18

61602-1-I

83265-0

State v. Victoria
Denied

19

61290-5-I

83269-2

State v. Hills
Denied

20

61679-0-I

83277-3

City of Seattle v. Jacob
Granted

21

26200-6-III
consol. w/
27152-8-III

83505-5

State v. Bremer;
In re Pers. Restraint of Bremer
Petition for review and all other motions are denied

22

37540-1-II

83523-3

State v. Hopson
Denied

23

57613-5-I

81215-2

State v. Jolliffe
Continued to December 3, 2009, En Banc Conference

24

37517-6-II

83133-5

Smith v. Safeco Ins. Co.
Denied

25

61073-2-I

83168-8

State v. Hence
Denied

26

26896-9-III

83241-2

State v. Cuellar
Denied

27

61307-3-I

83247-1

State v. Franklin
Denied

28

62066-5-I

83248-0

State v. Williams
Denied

29

61092-9-I

83249-8

State v. Kahlon
Denied

30

60879-7-I

83251-0

State v. George
Denied

31

61549-1-I

83274-9

State v. Winningham
Denied

Department Two

November 4, 2009
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No Court of Appeals
Cause Number		 Supreme Court
Cause Number

Case Name

1

61838-5-I

83176-9

Felt v. City of Bellevue
Denied

2

38399-3-II

83180-7

In re Marriage of Young & Remy
Denied

3

60909-2-I

83218-8

Fairhaven Land & Livestock Co. v. Chuckanut Trails Water Ass’n
Deny petition for review; deny Brisbane’s motion to file reply

4

37194-4-II

83235-8

Cox v. O’Brien;
O’Brien Home Inspection Servs. v. Demers;
Demers v. Cox
Denied

5

62168-8-I

83307-9

Curtis v. Lein
Granted

6

36562-6-II

83308-7

State v. Ish
Granted only on vouching issue

7

61571-8-I

83310-9

Woo v. Fireman’s Fund Ins. Co.
Denied

8

53246-4-I

83317-6

State v. Webster
Denied

9

61811-3-I

83320-6

Bennett v. Seattle Mental Health
Deferred pending Waples v. Yi #82142-9

10

37653-9-II

83322-2

State v. Butler
Denied

11

36407-7-II

83324-9

State v. Reed
Denied

12

36407-7-II

83329-0

State v. Hagler
Denied

13

58705-1-I

83328-1

Ledcor Indus., Inc. v. Mut. of Enumclaw Ins. Co.
Denied

14

37585-1-II

83340-1

State v. Jackson
Denied

15

60991-2-I

83343-5

State v. Immelt
Granted

16

61125-9-I

83344-3

State v. Bander
Continued to December 3, 2009, En Banc Conference

17

61924-1-I

83345-1

Eastgate I-90 Office Bldg. P’ship v. Woodley
Deny petition for review; Grant Respondent’s request for attorney fees

18

26033-0-III

83352-4

Pac. Land Partners v. State
Deny petition for review; Deny motion to strike

19

61319-7-I

83271-4

State v. Fuentes
Deferred pending Meneses #83172-6

20

61118-6-I

83172-6

State v. Meneses
Granted only on three issues; double jeopardy, jury instructions on intent and lesser included offenses

21

61963-2-I

83305-2

State v. Shuffelen
Denied

22

58163-5-I

80837-6

Cruson v. A.A.A.A., Inc.
Denied

23

36656-8-II

82325-1

State v. Torrey
Denied

24

36639-8-II

82980-2

State v. Day
Deny petition for review and all other motions

25

37212-6-II

83142-4

State v. Givens
Denied

26

36761-1-II

83220-0

State v. Evatt
Denied

27

37863-9-II

83224-2

State v. Dickinson
Denied

28

61207-7-I

83225-1

State v. Khan
Denied

29

36848-0-II

83232-3

State v. Edington
Denied

30

61743-5-I

83323-1

State v. Myers
Denied

31

60067-2-I

83332-0

Wong v. Richards
Denied

32

37997-0-II

83341-9

In re Parentage of Aheren
Denied

 

  

Privacy and Disclaimer Notices Sitemap

© Copyright 2025. Washington State Administrative Office of the Courts.

S3