Washington State Courts - Supreme Court Petitions for Review

Petitions for Review
July 10, 2012

The following are the results of the petitions for review considered by a department of the Supreme Court on July 10, 2012.

Department One
Department Two

Department One

July 10, 2012
Petitions for Review
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No	Court of Appeals Cause Number	Supreme Court Cause No	Case Name
1	61811-3-I	87095-1	Bennett v. Seattle Mental Health, et al. Denied
2	29055-7-III	87135-3	State v. Lawrence Denied
3	29172-3-III	87147-7	State v. Pavlik Denied
4	40692-6-II	87155-8	State v. Nettlebeck Denied
5	65933-2-I	87158-2	State v. Woods Denied
6	40491-5-II	87160-4	State v. Chapman Denied
7	29170-7-III	87163-9	State v. Ozuna Denied
8	29207-0-III	87176-1	Schwartz v. Elerding Denied
9	41293-4-II	87193-1	Germeau v. Mason County, et al. Denied
10	41265-9-II	87205-8	Malich Motors, Inc. v. Regal Marine Indus., Inc. Deny petition for review; Respondent's request for sanctions is denied
11	66373-9-I	87208-2	State v. Ali Divsar aka Ali Ay Denied
12	29875-2-III	87217-1	Zapotocky v. Dalton Denied
13	65605-8-I	87218-0	State v. Gibbs Continued to September 5, 2012, Department One
14	66102-7-I	87231-7	Int’l Marine Underwriters v. ABCD Marine, LLC, et al. Denied
15	29212-6-III	87241-4	Doyle v. Lee, et al. Deny petition for review; deny issue raised in Respondent Lee's answer; grant Respondent Lee's request for attorney fees
16	66150-7-I	87090-0	State v. Densmore Denied
17	38472-8-II	85608-7	State v. Louthan Granted
18	40687-0-II	86789-5	Westberry v. Interstate Distrib. Co. Denied
19	62732-5-I	84983-8	State v. Mills Grant and remand to the Court of Appeals for reconsideration only on the issue of the lawfulness of the car search in light of State v. Snapp, 174 Wn.2d at 197, State v. Robinson 171 Wn.2d 292, 306, 253 P.3d 84 (2011) and State v. Afana, 169 Wn.2d 169, 184, 233 P.3d 879 (2010)
20	38876-6-II	85266-9	State v. Chesley Grant and remand to the trial court for a suppression hearing
21	39617-3-II	85717-2	State v. Swetz Denied
22	65308-3-I	87052-7	State v. Coston Deny Petitioner's motion for waiver of filing fee
23	30108-7-III	87063-2	Edwards v. Spokane Police Officers, B. Cestnik, et al. Denied
24	65015-7-I	87066-7	Hegyi v. Abu-Najem & Wash. State Dep’t of Transp. (WSDOT) Nw. Region (NWR) Deny petition for review; deny Respondent's motion to dismiss; deny Petitioner's emergency motion for continuance
25	41307-8-II	87125-6	State v. Berlin Denied
26	66522-7-I	87169-8	Levy v. Snohomish Co. Deny Petitioner's motion for waiver of filing fee
27	28985-1-III consol/w 28986-9-III	87179-5	State v. Landrum Deferred pending State v. Tarhan #85737-7
28	65847-6-I	87190-6	State v. MacMillan Grant and remand to Court of Appeals for reconsideration in light of Guzman Nunez #85789-0
29	40513-0-II	87192-2	In re Marriage of Benner Denied
30	65923-5-I	87194-9	State v. Lewis Denied
31	65715-1-I	87212-1	State v. Laird Deferred pending State v. Sublett & Olsen #84856-4
32	29094-8-III	87254-6	State v. Shepard Denied
33	66038-1-I	87260-1	State v. Taylor Denied

Department Two

July 10, 2012
Petitions for Review
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No	Court of Appeals Cause Number	Supreme Court Cause No	Case Name
1	66162-1-I	87098-5	Connor v. King Deny petition for review; deny Respondent's request for attorney fees
2	29804-3-III	87121-3	Smith v. Stockdale, et al. Denied
3	29649-1-III	87146-9	Lepiane v. Irreantum, LLC, et al. Deny petition for review; grant Respondents' request for attorney fees
4	29474-9-III	87148-5	State v. Toscano Denied
5	61167-4-I	87153-1	State v. Moi Continued to September 6, 2012, En Banc Conference
6	65943-0-I	87159-1	State v. Vincent Denied
7	27535-3-III	87161-2	State v. Mendez, et al. Denied
8	28958-3-III	87164-7	State v. Monaghan Denied
9	29010-7-III	87166-3	State v. Posey Denied
10	39514-2-II consol/w 39524-0-II & 39520-7-II	87173-6	State v. Kiliona-Garramone, et al. Denied
11	41470-8-II	87174-4	Columbia Cmty. Bank v. Newman Park, LLC Continued to September 6, 2012, En Banc Conference
12	29918-0-III	87177-9	Double H, L.P. v. Wash. Dep’t of Ecology Denied
13	29464-1-III	87178-7	State v. Zigan Denied
14	41353-1-II	87189-2	Lord v. Pierce County Denied
15	41507-1-II	87191-4	Sequim Valley Ranch, LLC v. Graysmarsh, LLC, et al. Denied
16	38411-6-II consol. w/ 41021-4-II	87210-4	Vision One, LLC v. Philadelphia Ins. Co., et al. Denied
17	40752-3-II	87215-5	Chicago Title Ins. Co. v. State, Office of the Ins. Comm’r Granted
18	29349-1-III	87219-8	Sipes v. Bangert Denied
19	29461-7-III	87220-1	State v. Mills Grant and remand to the Court of appeals only on the SSOSA issue
20	41138-5-II	87221-0	Mason, et al. v. Georgia-Pacific Corp. Deny petition for review; grant Respondent's request for attorney fees
21	66125-6-I	87237-6	Jones v. Town of Hunts Point Deny petition for review; grant Respondent's motion to strike reply of Petitioner; grant Respondent's request for attorney fees for answering petition for review; deny Respondent's request for attorney fees for filing motion to strike
22	65523-0-I	87245-7	Russell v. Maas Denied
23	65936-7-I	87257-1	Rice v. Offshore Sys., Inc. Denied
24	66967-2-I	86831-0	State v. Malakowsky Continued to September 6, 2012, En Banc Conference
25	62241-2-I consol. w/ 62641-8-I 62741-4-I	84685-5	State v. Arntsen Grant Arntsen's petition for review only on the lawfulness of the search of his car & remand to the Court of Appeals in light of State v. Snapp, 275 P.3d 289 (2012) & State v. Robinson, 171 Wn.2d 292 (2011)
26	62076-2-I	84909-9	State v. Jordan Grant review only on issue of lawfulness of the search of the car & remand to the Court of Appeals for reconsideration in light of State v. Snapp, 275 P.3d 289 (2012)
27	40450-8-II	87103-5	State v. Burns Denied
28	65465-9-I	87156-6	State v. Spring Denied
29	28567-7-III	87167-1	State v. Ehart Denied
30	41269-1-II	87195-7	State v. Olson Denied
31	41658-1-II	87199-0	State v. Sherman Denied
32	65176-5-I	87248-1	State v. Pitchford Deny review of the issues raised in the Respondent's answer; the State's petition for review is granted only on the issue of the firearm enhancement and remand to the Court of Appeals for reconsideration in light of State v. Guzman Nunez #85789-0.