Washington State Courts - Supreme Court Petitions for Review

Petitions for Review
September 8, 2009

The following are the results of the petitions for review considered by a department of the Supreme Court on September 8, 2009.

Department One
Department Two

Department One

September 8, 2009
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No	Court of Appeals Cause Number	Supreme Court Cause Number	Case Name
1	26432-7-III	82531-9	Guillen v. Contreras Granted
2	26793-8-III	82826-1	Baldwin v. Silver Petition for review denied. Respondent’s request for attorneys fees is denied
3	26880-2-III	82827-0	Washington Trust Bank v. River Gorge Granted
4	26667-2-III	82828-8	Johnson v. Camp Auto., d/b/a Camp Chevrolet Cadillac Denied
5	26604-4-III	82829-6	Hensley v. Colville Sch. Dist. Denied
6	36895-1-II	82833-4	Bonneville, a/k/a Ellwanger v. Pierce County Denied
7	37468-4-II	83087-8	Bonneville v. Pierce County Denied
8	36539-1-II	82840-7	State v. Williams Denied
9	37079-4-II	82845-8	Internet Cmty. & Entm’t Corp., d/b/a Betcha.com v. State Granted
10	26492-1-III	82850-4	State v. Angulo Deferred pending State v. Dow #81243-8
11	26620-6-III	82851-2	Pratt v. Davey Petition for Review denied. Respondent’s request for attorney fees is granted
12	26573-1-III	82852-1	State v. Doughty Granted
13	26671-1-III	82853-9	State v. Gray Denied
14	36540-5-II	82854-7	Jaeger v. Cleaver Constr., Inc. Denied
15	26124-7-III	82855-5	State v. Montano Granted
16	37173-1-II	82872-5	Kitsap County Deputy Sheriff’s Guild v. Kitsap County Denied
17	36492-1-II	82907-1	In re Det. of Hawkins Granted
18	34780-6-II	82911-0	Samson v. City of Bainbridge Island Continued to September 30, 2009, En Banc Conference
19	37015-8-II	82912-8	In re The 1934 Deed to Camp Kilworth Denied
20	61006-6-I consol. w/ 61507-6-I	82916-1	Berg Holdings v. Pinnacle Realty Mgmt. Co. Stricken - Joint Motion to Dismiss granted 9/8/09
21	60308-6-I	82969-1	State v. Wallin Denied
22	59701-9-I	82972-1	State v. Releford Denied
23	60012-5-I	82975-6	State v. Buzzell Continued to September 30, 2009, En Banc Conference
24	61452-5-I	82983-7	State v. Matic Denied
25	61078-3-I	82994-2	State v. Champaco Denied
26	36299-6-II	82995-1	State v. Moeurn Petition for review granted only on the offender score issue
27	26894-2-III	82996-9	Bowens v. Empire Fire & Marine Ins.â€”Bond #FS802133 Denied
28	36961-3-II	82997-7	Metro. Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. v. Pers. Rep. of Johnson Denied
29	61272-7-I	82998-5	James v. Momah Petition for review granted and remanded to the Court of Appeals with instructions to reinstate appeal
30	61045-7-I	82999-3	State v. Fisher Denied
31	27102-1-III	83003-7	McGinnity v. Autonation, Inc. Petition for review denied. Respondent’s request for attorneys fees is granted
32	37023-9-III	83012-6	State v. Seppa Denied
33	36626-6-II	83015-1	Trotzer v. Vig Denied
34	61178-0-I	83021-5	State v. Pelfrey Denied
35	55572-3-I	83023-1	In re Det. of Post Continued to September 29, 2009, Department One calendar
36	37352-1-II	83144-1	State v. Jagger Denied
37	57613-5-I	81215-2	State v. Jolliffe Continued to September 29, 2009, Department One calendar
38	58659-9-I	81265-9	State v. McGee Continued to September 30, 2009, En Banc Conference
39	25881-5-III	82825-3	State v. Zbylski Denied
40	36936-2-II	82838-5	State v. Tyrer Denied
41	36755-6-II	82839-3	State v. Wingate Deferred pending State v. Williams-Walker #78611-9
42	36803-0-II	82859-8	State v. Hovig Denied
43	37095-6-II	82873-3	State v. Cahill Denied
44	36836-6-II	82875-0	State v. Latimer Denied
45	26831-4-III	82877-6	State v. Pace Denied
46	60448-1-I	82890-3	State v. Lewis Denied
47	61337-5-I	82908-0	State v. Hays Denied
48	37003-4-II	82909-8	State v. Petersen Denied
49	36444-1-II	82910-1	State v. Wofford Deferred pending State v. Bunker #81921-1
50	36734-3-II	82914-4	State v. Field Denied
51	61707-9-I	82974-8	State v. Milojevich Denied
52	61056-2-I	82976-4	State v. Sandoval Denied
53	61413-4-I	82977-2	State v. Gonzales-Frias Denied
54	61038-4-I	82978-1	State v. Stewart Denied
55	60753-7-I	82982-9	State v. King Deferred pending State v. Bunker #81921-1
56	61457-6-I	82984-5	State v. Chen Denied
57	37078-6-II	82991-8	State v. League Continued to September 30, 2009, En Banc Conference
58	36929-0-II	83001-1	State v. Bishop Deferred pending State v. Erickson #81594-1
59	36966-4-II	83019-3	State v. Kerr Denied
60	60769-3-I	83022-3	State v. Linerud, a/k/a Cain Petition for review granted and remanded to the Court of Appeals in light of In re PRP of Brooks #80704-3
61	61141-1-I	83275-7	State v. Rodriguez Deferred pending State v. Bunker (81921-1) and State v. Hall (82558-1). Motion to consolidate is denied

PRV MOTIONS

60323-0-I

83170-0

State v. Romero
Petitioner’s motion for extension of time to file petition for review is granted. The petition for review is denied

Department Two

September 8, 2009
Petitions for Review:
Note: Granted petitions are shaded.

No	Court of Appeals Cause Number	Supreme Court Cause Number	Case Name
1	61137-2-I	82922-5	Rollins v. King County Metro Transit Denied
2	61701-0-I	82923-3	Dumont v. City of Seattle Denied
3	61652-8-I	82924-1	Faghih v. State Dep’t of Health Denied
4	60949-1-I	82928-4	State v. Pedro, a/k/a Pedro-Guerra Deferred pending State v. Kelley (#82111-9) and State v. Aguirre (#82226-3)
5	61019-8-I	82929-2	State v. Waldon Denied
6	27190-1-III	82935-7	State v. Aljutily Denied
7	26609-5-III consol. w/ 26585-4-III	82942-0	State v. Drake; In re Pers. Restraint of Drake Denied
8	26842-0-III	82949-7	In re Marriage of Chua & Root Denied
9	25398-8-III	82950-1	Forbes v. Am. Bldg. Maint. Co. W. Forbes’ petition granted only on prejudgment interest and modification of settlement amount issues; Schultz’ petition denied
10	26564-1-III	82952-7	Estep v. Hamilton Denied
11	26771-7-III	82957-8	State v. Posey Deferred pending PRP of Manro #81600-0
12	26758-0-III	82958-6	State v. McLane Denied
13	36683-5-II	82959-4	State v. Charles Denied
14	26843-8-III	82960-8	Breuer v. Presta Deferred pending Waples v. Yi #82142-9
15	36294-5-II	82961-6	Sch. Dists.’ Alliance for Adequate Funding of Spec. Educ. v. State Granted
16	36241-4-II	82967-5	State v. Rogers Denied
17	60177-6-I	82988-8	State v. Fallentine Denied
18	59519-9-I	82993-4	Estate of Corbitt v. Experimental Aircraft Ass’n Denied
19	61636-6-I	83028-2	Beriault v. King Denied
20	59956-9-I	83029-1	Brinton v. Codoni Denied
21	60163-6-I	83030-4	Burton v. Twin Commander Aircraft LLC Continued to Sepember 30, 2009, En Banc Conference
22	60958-1-I	83031-2	State v. Davis Denied
23	61226-3-I	83038-0	Smith v. Orthopedics Int’l, Ltd., P.S. Granted
24	61779-6-I	83040-1	Rousso v. State Granted
25	60451-1-I	83041-0	MacDonald v. Mutual of Enumclaw Denied
26	26459-9-III	83045-2	Herman v. State Shorelines Hearings Bd. Denied
27	36600-2-II	83059-2	In re Det. of Sease Denied
28	27047-5-III	83063-1	State v. Hopkins Denied
29	60911-4-I	83066-5	State v. Hills Denied; motion for accelerated review and motion for default denied
30	36890-1-II	83091-6	K.H. v. ADT Sec. Sys., Inc. Denied
31	61445-2-I	83093-2	State v. Carneh Denied
32	60533-0-I	83098-3	Fahim v. Flemmer Deny petition for review. Respondent’s request for attorney fees is denied
33	35976-6-II	83102-5	State v. Hockaday Denied
34	60259-4-I	83103-3	Mitchell v. A.F. Evans Co. (d/b/a A.F. Evans Mfg. Group) Denied
35	59528-8-I	81780-4	State v. Reeves Granted and remanded to Court of Appeals for reconsideration in light of State v. Sutherby, 165 Wn.2d 870 (2009)
36	61443-6-I	82691-9	State v. Curry Denied
37	60442-2-I	82926-8	State v. Xavier Denied
38	61174-7-I	82927-6	State v. Lewis Denied
39	26837-3-III	82931-4	State v. Ramirez Denied
40	61098-8-I	82932-2	State v. Nart, a/k/a Emirov Denied
41	26485-8-III	82934-9	State v. Dalluge Deny petition for review. All other motions are denied as moot
42	26695-8-III	82937-3	State v. King Denied
43	26794-6-III	82953-5	State v. Craddock Denied
44	60648-4-I	82963-2	State v. Price Denied
45	26499-8-III	82964-1	State v. Francisco Denied
46	25671-5-III	82965-9	State v. Foos Denied
47	61306-5-I	83032-1	State v. McGhee Denied
48	58359-0-I	83039-8	State v. Romero Deferred pending State v. Bunker #81921-1
49	37242-8-II	83044-4	State v. Miller Denied
50	26119-1-III	83048-7	State v. Key Denied
51	37304-1-II	83058-4	State v. Blodgett Denied
52	27059-9-III	83062-2	State v. Lexing Denied
53	61429-1-I	83084-3	State v. Solem Denied
54	60917-3-I	83085-1	State v. Paulson Denied
55	36998-2-II	83086-0	State v. Perez Denied
56	61511-4-I	83094-1	Clark v. Moore Denied
57	37673-3-II	83095-9	State v. Haggard Denied
58	26905-1-III	83104-1	State v. Quantrille Denied
59	26960-4-III	83105-0	State v. McNeil Continued to September 29, 2009, Department Two
60	37743-8-II	83107-6	State v. Cellestine Denied

PRV MOTIONS

23	37305-0-II	83113-1	State v. Haight Petitioner’s motion for extension of time to file petition for review is granted. The petition for review is granted and remanded to the Court of Appeals in light of Arizona v. Gant, 129 S.Ct. 1710
25	61753-2-I	83177-7	State v. S.J.W. Petitioner’s motion for extension of time to file petition for review is granted. State’s petition for review is granted. Respondent Webb’s contingent issues are denied

Pattern Jury Instructions

Privacy and Disclaimer Notices Sitemap

Petitions for Review September 8, 2009

Department One

Department Two

Petitions for Review
September 8, 2009