|
1377 - Add a 'convictions only' tab in JABS
|
|
Request Status Summary |
Request Status |
Authorized |
|
Request Detail |
Requestor Name: |
|
Stromberger, Aaron W |
Origination Date: |
|
04/15/2024 |
|
|
Recommended Endorser:
|
|
Superior Court Judges' Association |
|
Request Type: |
Change or Enhancement
|
Which Systems are affected? |
Judicial Access Browser System (JABS)
|
Other affected Systems / Business Processes |
Spokane County Pretrial Services |
Business Area: |
Case History
|
Communities Impacted: |
AOC
Supreme Court Justices
Supreme Court Clerks
Supreme Court Judicial Asst.
Appellate Court Judges
Appellate Court Clerks
Superior Court Judges
County Clerks
Superior Court Administrators
Family and Juvenile Law Judges
Juvenile Court Administrators
State Agencies
|
Impact if not Resolved: |
Medium |
Impact Description: |
Defendants with lengthy arrest histories can be difficult to view in JABS. Too many case types and judgment codes are mixed together in one long, running list. Conviction information could get misidentified or overlooked.
Pretrial risk assessment tools are becoming more widely used throughout the state. Many risk tools are scored based on prior conviction history. Misidentifying a single conviction could alter the defendant's risk score in a negative way. Having a tab of confirmed convictions could help ensure accuracy and reduce human error.
|
|
|
What is the Business Problem or Opportunity |
JABS currently lists felony and misdemeanor convictions under the ICH, DCH, and PDCH links on the top row of a defendant case history search. Convicted charges are currently listed alongside other pending charges, dismissed charges, charges that were not filed, deferred charges, and infractions.
It would be a tremendous benefit to have an additional tab along the top row that only listed cases (and specific charges) that resulted in a guilty finding. This new tab could be labeled 'CONV'.
AOC once created a BIT report for Spokane County Pretrial Services that pulled conviction information from JIS. It was greatly beneficial to the department at the time. This BIT report is no longer reliable as JIS is missing case information from King County and other cases from Odyssey. It is unclear if a similar report could be generated from JABS, but a conviction tab in JABS would serve a similar purpose.
All of this data currently exists in JABS. We are simply requesting that conviction data be displayed in a more focused and reader-friendly format.
|
Expected Benefit: |
Judges, attorneys, and court staff would be able to quicky sort through criminal history data and review a defendant's conviction history, without having to navigate through a multitude of pending and dismissed cases. This new tab would provide a quick, easy-to-read list of a defendant's conviction history.
Spokane County Pretrial Services prepares first appearance evaluations for both Superior and District Courts, assisting the court's decisions on pretrial release. The reports include all felony, misdemeanor, and juvenile conviction history from Washington State. Convictions are manually counted and entered into a report, which is time-consuming and labor-intensive. Having a 'convictions' tab in JABS that narrowed down criminal history data to just convictions would reduce human error and save time and labor for the department.
There are other Pretrial Services agencies throughout the State that prepare evaluations or risk assessments for their local courts. They too could benefit from a conviction tab in JABS to assist their efforts.
|
Endorsement Detail
|
Endorsing Committee |
|
Superior Court Judges' Association |
Endorser Name: |
|
Arsenio Escudero on behalf of SCJA |
Origination Date: |
|
05/01/2024 |
|
Endorsing Action: |
Endorsed |
Endorser’s Explanation and Comments |
Judge Amamilo (SCJA) Comments and Questions
* Family law courts use this information in child custody, DV, and guardianship cases.
* What is the downside, if any, of adding this tab?
*Criminal litigants rely on the "conviction history" to determine a basis for the court to make findings at prelims: likely failure to appear, likely to commit a violent offense, likely to intimidate witnesses or interfere with the administration of justice.
|
|
|
AOC Analysis Detail
|
Analysis Date: |
06/21/2024
|
Request Rationale |
Aligns with JIS Business Priorities, IT Strategies & Plans: |
Yes |
Aligns with applicable policies and with ISD Standards: |
Yes |
Breadth of Solution Benefit: |
Narrow |
Cost Estimates |
Cost to Implement? |
$14,500 to $43,600 |
Feasibility Study needed? |
No |
Court Level User Group |
Superior Courts |
Approving Authority |
CIO |
|
Request Summary: |
This is a request to add a 'Conviction Only' tab in JABS, which will display only those cases and specific charges against defendants that resulted in a guilty finding.
|
Business Impacts: |
This change will provide the following benefits:
• It will enable JABS users to quickly review convicted cases on a single page.
• It will eliminate the need to sift through lengthy case lists of all statuses to find only those cases that resulted in a guilty finding.
|
Summary of Proposed Solution |
The proposed solution includes two options:
• Option 1: Create a new hyperlink called 'CONV' and place it next to the existing ICH, DCH and PDCH hyperlinks on the case history page in JABS. This new page should be tied to the user's JIS security role. When a user with the required permissions accesses this page, it will display only cases and specific charges that resulted in a guilty finding.
• Option 2: Create a new checkbox labeled 'Convictions Only' and place it above the existing ICH, DCH, PDCH hyperlinks on the case history page in JABS. When a user selects this checkbox and visits either of the pages on: ICH, DCH or PDCH, the page will display only cases and specific charges that resulted in a guilty finding.
|
Proposed Solution |
AOC proposes the following solution with two options:
1) Create a new hyperlink called 'CONV' and position it alongside the existing ICH, DCH, PDCH hyperlinks on the case history page in JABS. This option provides the following enhancements:
a. A new hyperlink called 'CONV' will be added next to ICH, DCH and PDCH.
b. Clicking the 'CONV' hyperlink will reload the case history section to display only cases and charges that resulted in a guilty finding.
c. The 'CONV' hyperlink can be made accessible to users who currently have access to any of the three hyperlinks: ICH, DCH, PDCH.
d. Access to 'CONV' hyperlink can also be limited to users who have access to DCH and will not be available to users with access only to ICH or PDCH.
2) Introduce a new checkbox titled 'Convictions Only' above the existing ICH, DCH, PDCH hyperlinks on the case history page in JABS. This option provides the following benefits:
a. A checkbox labeled 'Convictions only' will be positioned above the existing hyperlinks ICH, DCH and PDCH.
b. This will be an optional, selectable, checkbox. When checked, depending on the page being viewed (ICH/DCH/PDCH), the case history section will refresh to show only cases and charges that resulted in guilty finding.
c. No need to create any new security rules for viewing cases with convictions only.
d. No changes to the existing user access requirements for the ICH, DCH or PDCH pages.
e. All user roles will be able to utilize this new feature on all three pages: ICH, DCH & PDCH.
Additionally, updates to the JABS user manuals are required to include information about the new hyperlink 'CONV' or checkbox, detailing who can access these tools and what information they will display.
|
Additional Systems Affected |
Judicial Access Browser System (JABS)
|
Communities Impacted |
AOC
Supreme Court Justices
Supreme Court Clerks
Supreme Court Judicial Asst.
Appellate Court Judges
Appellate Court Clerks
Superior Court Judges
County Clerks
Superior Court Administrators
Family and Juvenile Law Judges
Juvenile Court Administrators
State Agencies
|
|
|
Confirmation of Endorsing Action Detail
|
Endorsing Committee |
|
Superior Court Judges' Association |
Endorser Name: |
|
Escudero, Arsenio of behalf of the SCJA Endorsement Group |
Origination Date: |
|
07/01/2024 |
|
Endorsing Action: |
Endorsed |
|
|
Court Level User Group Decision Detail
|
CLUG |
Superior Courts |
Chair of Group |
Arsenio Escudero on behalf of the Superior Court Level User Group |
Date of Decision |
07/22/2024 |
Decision |
Decision to Recommend for Approval |
Unamimously recommended to the approving authority |
Priority Processing Status |
Prioritized |
|
Scoring Detail |
In making their decision, detailed score values were not provided by Superior Courts.
|
|
Pros & Cons (if vote is not unanimous) |
NA
|
Additional Notes |
The SCLUG has prioritized this ITG as SCLUG Priority #7.
|
|
Implementation Detail
|
Analysis Date: |
|
Implementation Stage
|
Authorized
|
Prioritization Option:
|
Prioritized
|
|
|
|
|
|