Supreme Court Calendar

9:00 A.M.

Olympia

March 01, 2012

Case No. 1 - 200,917-4

COUNSEL

In re:

Thomas F. McGrath,
an Attorney at Law.

 

Kurt Bulmer
Francesca D'Angelo (WSBA)

SYNOPSIS: Is there enough evidence that Thomas McGrath knowingly made a misrepresentation to the court and caused harm to the legal system to justify suspending him from the practice of law?

Case No. 2 - 86021-1

COUNSEL

Duc Tan, et al.
     v.
Norman Le, et ux et al.

Gregory Rhodes
Kenneth Masters & Shelby Frost Lemmel
Nigel Malden/Rebecca Larson
Michael King & James Lobsenz
Howard Goodfriend

SYNOPSIS: Through a series of publications, Norman Le and other defendants accused Duc Tan and the Vietnamese Community of Thurston County (VCTC) of being under-cover Viet Cong agents and engaging in pro-communist activities. Plaintiffs argue defendants made false defamatory statements, not protected by the First Amendment, causing damages distinct from what would result from expressing the opinion that Tan and the VCTC are communists or communist sympathizers. Plaintiffs also claim that defendants made their statements with actual malice. Are they correct?


1:30 P.M.

Case No. 3 - 86119-6

COUNSEL

State of Washington
     v.
Bryan Edward Allen

Ann Summers/Deborah Dwyer & Dennis McCurdy
 
Susan Wilk

SYNOPSIS: In this criminal case, the Court must decide several issues, including whether the trial court erred by failing to give a jury instruction on cross-racial identification evidence and whether the prosecutor committed misconduct during closing argument.

Case No. 4 - 86145-5

COUNSEL

State of Washington
     v.
Brandon S. Coristine

Mark Lindsey & Andrew Metts, III
 
Lisa Tabbut

SYNOPSIS: The trial court instructed the jury about an affirmative defense, over defendant's objection. The jury found the defendant guilty. Was it unconstitutional to give the instruction? If so, was it harmless error?

These summaries are not formulated by the Court and are provided only for the convenience of the public.

 

Privacy and Disclaimer NoticesSitemap

© Copyright 2024. Washington State Administrative Office of the Courts.

S3