Note: This opinion is no longer available on this site. To find the official opinion go the Washington State Judicial Opinions Website


Supreme Court of the State of Washington

Opinion Information Sheet

Docket Number: 85535-8
Title of Case: Macias v. Saberhagen Holdings, Inc.
File Date: 08/09/2012
Oral Argument Date: 10/20/2011

SOURCE OF APPEAL
----------------
Appeal from Pierce County Superior Court
 08-2-09564-4
 Honorable Vicki L. Hogan

JUSTICES
--------
Barbara A. MadsenMajority Author
Charles W. JohnsonSigned Dissent
Tom ChambersSigned Majority
Susan OwensSigned Dissent
Mary E. FairhurstSigned Majority
James M. JohnsonDissent Author
Debra L. StephensSigned Majority
Charles K. WigginsSigned Majority
Steven C. GonzálezDid Not Participate
Gerry L. Alexander,
Justice Pro Tem.
Signed Dissent

COUNSEL OF RECORD
-----------------

Counsel for Petitioner(s)
 John Wentworth Phillips  
 Phillips Law Group PLLC
 315 5th Ave S Ste 1000
 Seattle, WA, 98104-2682

 John Matthew Geyman  
 Phillips Law Group PLLC
 315 5th Ave S Ste 1000
 Seattle, WA, 98104-2682

 Matthew Phineas Bergman  
 Bergman Draper Ladenburg, PLLC
 614 1st Ave Fl 4
 Seattle, WA, 98104-2233

 Brian F Ladenburg  
 Bergman Draper Ladenburg, PLLC
 614 1st Ave Fl 4
 Seattle, WA, 98104-2233

Counsel for Respondent(s)
 Paul Joseph Kundtz  
 Riddell Williams PS
 1001 4th Ave Ste 4500
 Seattle, WA, 98154-1065

 Wendy E Lyon  
 Riddell Williams PS
 1001 4th Ave Ste 4500
 Seattle, WA, 98154-1065

 Kevin Carl Baumgardner  
 Corr Cronin Michelson Baumgardner & Pree
 1001 4th Ave Ste 3900
 Seattle, WA, 98154-1051

 Daniel Joseph Gunter  
 Riddell Williams PS
 1001 4th Ave Ste 4500
 Seattle, WA, 98154-1065

 Anthony Todaro  
 Corr Cronin
 1001 4th Ave Ste 3900
 Seattle, WA, 98154-1051

 Timothy Lee Ashcraft  
 Williams Kastner & Gibbs
 1301 A St Ste 900
 Tacoma, WA, 98402-4299

 Robert Joseph Sexton  
 Attorney at Law
 Po Box 151
 Toppenish, WA, 98948-0151

 Randy Jarl Aliment  
 Williams Kastner & Gibbs
 601 Union St Ste 4100
 Seattle, WA, 98101-2380

 Timothy Kost Thorson  
 Carney Badley & Spellman
 701 5th Ave Ste 3600
 Seattle, WA, 98104-7010

Amicus Curiae on behalf of Pacific Legal Foundation
 Brian Trevor Hodges  
 Pacific Legal Foundation
 10940 Ne 33rd Pl Ste 210
 Bellevue, WA, 98004-1432

 Deborah J La Fetra  
 Pacific Legal Foundation
 3900 Lennane Drive
 Suite 200
 Sacramento, CA, 95834

Amicus Curiae on behalf of Washington State Association for
 Bryan Patrick Harnetiaux  
 Attorney at Law
 517 E 17th Ave
 Spokane, WA, 99203-2210

 George M Ahrend  
 Ahrend Albrecht PLLC
 16 Basin St Sw
 Ephrata, WA, 98823-1865

Amicus Curiae on behalf of National Association of Manufact
 Mark Behrens  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Cary Silverman  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 James Otis NeetJr.  
 Attorney at Law
 2555 Grand Blvd
 Kansas City, MO, 64108-2613

 Quentin Riegel  
 National Ass'n of Manufacturers
 1331 Pennsylvania Ave Nw
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Robin S Conrad  
 Nat'l Chamber Litigation Center
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Kate Comerford Todd  
 National Chamber Litigation Center, Inc.
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Sean Mcmurrough  
 Prop Casualty Insurers Assoc of Am.
 2600 South River Rd
 Des Plaines, IL, 60018-3286

 Lynda Mounts  
 American Ins. Association
 2101 L Street Nw Suite 400
 Washington, DC, 20037

 Donald Evans  
 American Chemistry Council
 700 Second Street Ne
 Washington, DC, 20002

Amicus Curiae on behalf of COAlition for Litigation Justice
 Mark Behrens  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Cary Silverman  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 James Otis NeetJr.  
 Attorney at Law
 2555 Grand Blvd
 Kansas City, MO, 64108-2613

 Quentin Riegel  
 National Ass'n of Manufacturers
 1331 Pennsylvania Ave Nw
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Robin S Conrad  
 Nat'l Chamber Litigation Center
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Kate Comerford Todd  
 National Chamber Litigation Center, Inc.
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Sean Mcmurrough  
 Prop Casualty Insurers Assoc of Am.
 2600 South River Rd
 Des Plaines, IL, 60018-3286

 Lynda Mounts  
 American Ins. Association
 2101 L Street Nw Suite 400
 Washington, DC, 20037

 Donald Evans  
 American Chemistry Council
 700 Second Street Ne
 Washington, DC, 20002

Amicus Curiae on behalf of Chambers of Commerce of the Us O
 Mark Behrens  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Cary Silverman  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 James Otis NeetJr.  
 Attorney at Law
 2555 Grand Blvd
 Kansas City, MO, 64108-2613

 Quentin Riegel  
 National Ass'n of Manufacturers
 1331 Pennsylvania Ave Nw
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Robin S Conrad  
 Nat'l Chamber Litigation Center
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Kate Comerford Todd  
 National Chamber Litigation Center, Inc.
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Sean Mcmurrough  
 Prop Casualty Insurers Assoc of Am.
 2600 South River Rd
 Des Plaines, IL, 60018-3286

 Lynda Mounts  
 American Ins. Association
 2101 L Street Nw Suite 400
 Washington, DC, 20037

 Donald Evans  
 American Chemistry Council
 700 Second Street Ne
 Washington, DC, 20002

Amicus Curiae on behalf of Property Casualty Insurers Assoc
 Mark Behrens  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Cary Silverman  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 James Otis NeetJr.  
 Attorney at Law
 2555 Grand Blvd
 Kansas City, MO, 64108-2613

 Quentin Riegel  
 National Ass'n of Manufacturers
 1331 Pennsylvania Ave Nw
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Robin S Conrad  
 Nat'l Chamber Litigation Center
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Kate Comerford Todd  
 National Chamber Litigation Center, Inc.
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Sean Mcmurrough  
 Prop Casualty Insurers Assoc of Am.
 2600 South River Rd
 Des Plaines, IL, 60018-3286

 Lynda Mounts  
 American Ins. Association
 2101 L Street Nw Suite 400
 Washington, DC, 20037

 Donald Evans  
 American Chemistry Council
 700 Second Street Ne
 Washington, DC, 20002

Amicus Curiae on behalf of American Insurance Associaton
 Mark Behrens  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Cary Silverman  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 James Otis NeetJr.  
 Attorney at Law
 2555 Grand Blvd
 Kansas City, MO, 64108-2613

 Quentin Riegel  
 National Ass'n of Manufacturers
 1331 Pennsylvania Ave Nw
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Robin S Conrad  
 Nat'l Chamber Litigation Center
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Kate Comerford Todd  
 National Chamber Litigation Center, Inc.
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Sean Mcmurrough  
 Prop Casualty Insurers Assoc of Am.
 2600 South River Rd
 Des Plaines, IL, 60018-3286

 Lynda Mounts  
 American Ins. Association
 2101 L Street Nw Suite 400
 Washington, DC, 20037

 Donald Evans  
 American Chemistry Council
 700 Second Street Ne
 Washington, DC, 20002

Amicus Curiae on behalf of American Chemistry Council
 Mark Behrens  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Cary Silverman  
 Shook Hardy & Bacon LLP
 1155 F Street Nw Suite 200
 Washington, DC, 20004

 James Otis NeetJr.  
 Attorney at Law
 2555 Grand Blvd
 Kansas City, MO, 64108-2613

 Quentin Riegel  
 National Ass'n of Manufacturers
 1331 Pennsylvania Ave Nw
 Washington, DC, 20004

 Robin S Conrad  
 Nat'l Chamber Litigation Center
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Kate Comerford Todd  
 National Chamber Litigation Center, Inc.
 1615 H Street Nw
 Washington, DC, 20062

 Sean Mcmurrough  
 Prop Casualty Insurers Assoc of Am.
 2600 South River Rd
 Des Plaines, IL, 60018-3286

 Lynda Mounts  
 American Ins. Association
 2101 L Street Nw Suite 400
 Washington, DC, 20037

 Donald Evans  
 American Chemistry Council
 700 Second Street Ne
 Washington, DC, 20002


  View the Slip Opinion(s) Filed for this Case.

  View a Printer Friendly Version of this Opinion Information Sheet.


 

Privacy and Disclaimer NoticesSitemap

© Copyright 2024. Washington State Administrative Office of the Courts.

S3